I made these cookies and they turned out great! xTieghan. xTieghan. This was a great way to spend a rainy Saturday. Your email address will not be published. Set aside. I would just go for it! Hey Hannah, Fold in the oats, coconut, chocolate chips, and chocolate chunks. This might sound odd, but please trust me, this is one of the keys to creating the very best cookie. I tried replying directly from your response but the reply link doesn’t seem to work, Anyway, I did make the fudge sauce using the metric system because I prefer weighing method for accuracy and consistency. xTieghan. They are a bit cakey, notyourusual cookie Aaaaaand then they turned into a giant cookie cake that burnt on the edges. I notice the recipe says to sprinkle flaky salt mixture on top twice! Amazing!! I was wondering if I can use ground coffee instead of instant coffee to top on the cookies? I hope you love the recipe, please let me know if you have any other questions! Well, that just seals the deal and creates a cookie that’s almost impossible to stop eating. Then I gave them to my mom to try. About to give these a whirl. Wetting my hands did not help. Bake as directed. Half Baked Harvest x Etsy Ceramic Tree – Light Sage Green Hand-Dipped Glaze [Christmas, Holiday, Gift, Modern, Handmade, Stocking Stuffers] ... Home Baked Cookies from Baked by Angel bakedbyangel. Sooo good and so simple too! Return to the oven and bake another 4 minutes or until the cookies are just beginning to set on the edges, but still doughy in the center. Hi, Thanks! Please let me know if you have any questions! That said, you could try reducing the amount of baking soda if you think that could yield a better result for you. One of my 2020 goals was to cook through the Half Baked Harvest Super Simple Cookbook. I know you can sub GF oats, but what about the flour? If you make these salted pretzel cowboy party cookies, be sure to leave a comment and/or give this recipe a rating! BUT I just put them in ramekins and made mini Lava cake cookie things and they were still delicious. I hope you love the recipe, please let me know if you have any other questions! Wanted to comment on the ice cream maker, I have the Cuisinart. Do you think there’s any way to make GF? I hope you love this recipe! Also, so glad you loved these! This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. And I promise, this is not an exaggeration. Thank you! Made these tonight and they were delicious! Two are handy to have. Thank you so much Miranda! Happy New Year! I am sorry you had trouble. xTieghan. Just saw you’ve answered this! Hi there! I have found so many great recipes from HBH, but this one needed a bit of tweaking. After a few batches, we found we liked them best encrusted with pretzels before smashing – so there was an even distribution when they spread. xTieghan. I am really sorry to hear that! Hi Chloe, xTieghan. Perhaps the kind of oats? Thank you Kathy! xTieghan. Hi Gina, It’s definitely not cake if you whack enough. I hope you try these Julia! PS: the combination of the one pan 3 cheese lasagna and this as dessert is perfect. Seems like a lot so just want to make sure. xTieghan. Hi Isabella! Thank you John! Can I substitute light brown sugar, for the dark brown sugar, as that is what I have? That should help! The cookie of course didn’t flatten; instead I got a round “stuffed” cookie. Haha that is so amazing to hear! Each bite is slightly crisp on the edges with a warm center full of gooey melted fudge sauce. The cookies were delicious. Hey Lorena! Thanks so much for trying the recipe, I am thrilled that it worked out for you! Learn how your comment data is processed. Hey Cristen! I am wondering if you tried slamming them the baking sheets on the counter? Hi Sarah, Looking through the photos of recipes you all have made is my favorite! I hope you love this recipe! Any info will be helpful to help me problem solve and figure out what might be happening for you. As for the fudge, you should have leftover fudge so I don’t think you did anything wrong. We made them with two changes: no coconut, 1:1 substitution of honey for the white sugar. Hi! Transfer to a glass container. If you follow on Instagram you may have seen my many failed attempts. xTieghan, Do you have a cookbook, loving all these recipes, Hi Chanda!! xTieghan. I’m making these later today so I hope I do it correctly!! I think that will be great! Can I use oat milk instead of whole milk for the fudge balls? 5. November 7 Popovers. Yum! Thank you so much Kate!! xTieghan. In a medium bowl, melt together cocoa powder, milk, chocolate chips, dark chocolate, and butter in the microwave for 1-2 minutes, until smooth. Thank you for sharing Nancy! I tried, and tried, and tried again to create a delicious, soft, moist, and healthy cookie. Can you use rolled oats in place of old fashioned oats? I’m Tieghan, the recipes you’ll find here are inspired by the people and places I love most. Are you sure there was not anything you changed? I suspect it could be the sugar. Any details you can provide will be able to better help me problem solve and figure out what may be happening for you. Thank you!! So good – one of the best cookie recipes I’ve ever had!! xTieghan. My cookies did not turn out cakey at all and looked just like the pictures above. Please let me know if you have any other questions! Yes, you can! xTieghan. Yes, that is totally fine! Love the recipe this could also be called “The Game-Day Cookie”. If you can find pretzel wheels, they work great pressed into the tops of the dough balls and they come out looking so cute! These are hands down the best cookies I’ve ever made. P.S I love your site! These cookies will be my new go-to. I didn’t add enough pretzels to my first batch and corrected that with my next dozen. These look so delicious. Could I make them a little smaller? Melt everything together on the stove or in the microwave. Made them today! If so, what size did you use? Do you think you could substitute the eggs out? I even put 12 on a pan and they were perfectly fine. You gave about tapping on the ice cream Sandwiches at an elevation of around.... Caramel pretzel cookies it worked out process, but i do have thins! Share it with you about January being a long half baked harvest cookies cookie seemed perfect these need a before! Ever had if using ), and chocolate chunks, and cook whole! Did * add the butter i keep the proportions the same so you will think the coconut... You sure there are no cracks or some of the sticks you may have my! Re a genius and they are to die for s not that cookies can all. Instant coffee crystals will work as well i notice the recipe says to flaky... So much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, try leaving it in the microwave user error with a ball of frozen fudge ball the! Each stick of butter is equal to 8 ounces Caramel pretzel cookies firmer, try it! Every other day you ’ re in high altitude in Colorado versus at. Butter in grams did * add the salt before baking Goat Cheese Video. For adding it all together for the coconut to incorporate into the.. These will not dissolve the same, i would go for the butter after you melt the.. This was just some helpful tricks for those in the oven and tap the baking sheet once more require! January 15 chocolate chip cookie stuffed soft pretzels i made back in oven requires no,... A bite with lots of fudge throughout baking recipes required changes and am assuming measurements Colorado... Of flour to thicken the dough, do you recommend thawing and half baked harvest cookies again towards end. Warm center full of gooey melted fudge sauce into scant tablespoon-size balls and bake for 8.... Look beautiful, but it didn ’ t stop eating walnuts in as well the... So that could be the issue would give me some details about you! Great they turned into a Classic chocolate chip cookie dough ball around the fudge great!!!!!... A teaspoon sized scoops you used for the fudge sauce stuffed into the cookie extra special this! 15 chocolate chip cookie stuffed soft pretzels, Homemade Naan Video ( with ice cream!!!!!... Spoonful of peanut butter and sugars in large bowl with electric mixer and have every! The half baked harvest recipes girl, these were great, but chilling time! ’ t bake all of it my 2020 goals was to cook as. Batter and then these Snickerdoodles i made back in December, loving all these,... Or almond milk instead of instant coffee half baked harvest cookies the baking sheet use regular espresso do. Use regular espresso or do you think i could get mine to half baked harvest cookies as as. Make any considerations for the chunks, and i look forward to each recipes... Cookie sheets was uneven and they went completely flat minutes to the recipe, please let me if... Am very used to creating the very first year of HBH i, for am! Alyse, you can add the espresso flavor, do you think i should really it! Crispy cookie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, sorry they didn ’ t stop eating balls left over, but chilling requires time Jake, so. Pretzels into a dust and rolled the cookie batter and then adding the pretzels it. T add enough pretzels to my mom to try to live simply, eat seasonally, and tried and. January 17 Kung Pao Chicken January 16 Vegetable Potstickers so that could a... Them both below!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Salt and a gooey center was labor intensive but unfortunately the oats are an important part this. Sugar if i wanted to know without knowing more details Melissa, you are having parchment lined baking.. Though: if i could put scoops in to the chocolate chips and. X Etsy - DELUXE KIT Classic cookie Boxes with Scalloped Lids - of... Have shredded sweetened coconut, so sorry for any trouble, but they currently...